Nostalgic

I remember this!

Sugar Shop's nostalgic assortment conjures memories and creates new ones!  We regularly hear joy in our customers voices with comments like: "I haven't had this since I was a kid!"  "My parents loved these!"  "My grandparents used to buy this for a penny!"  Everyone has a great candy story to tell.    

Artisanal

Handcrafted and Local

It's not surprising that local chocolatiers hold court in Sugar Shop.  Betsy's Buns, Mast Brothers, Liddabit Sweets, Cacao Prieto, and Tumbador are just a few of the amazing brands made in Brooklyn that you'll discover in our store.  You can even find some exclusive items, crafted just for us!

Bulk

Try some of each!

For kids and adults alike, our mind boggling assortment of bulk candy means that you can mix and match to your heart's content.  Grab some of your favorites and try something new.  Our selection is always changing.   We have everything from pucker inducing sours, to crave inducing dark chocolate, to smile inducing gummies.

A must to pick up on your visit.